Minnesota Network for Progressive Action


 
Politics Blogs - Blog Top Sites

Listed on BlogShares

 
site search

Site Meter
 
  Progressive Political Blog

Progressive Politics in Minnesota, the Nation, and the World

End of August Rankings: DFL Governor

Category: DFL Gov 2010
Posted: 08/31/09 14:57, Edited: 08/31/09 17:53

by Dave Mindeman
dmindeman06@yahoo.com

OK -- back to the lion's den and the end of the month rankings for the DFL Governor candidates. Ranking this large field is getting more difficult without some actual preference polling or public input. There are a number of variables which I'll discuss as we go along.

A couple of important notes. The DFL will be holding a September 15th straw poll (actually using ranked choice) at 3 different locations listed in the article. Although this is Rybak's home turf, the voting is open to anyone, so it may be a good indication of how well the candidates can mobilize supporters.

Secondly, mnpACT! continues its DFL Candidate for Governor series on Friday, September 11, (Open Circle Church in Burnsville) hosting John Marty and Paul Thissen. A good chance to get up close and personal with your questions.

Unlike the GOP, the DFL still has the likely potential that there will be a primary contest. So one of the things that will be watched closely is the financials. Candidates who can raise the money can gear up for a long primary contest. Those that can't come up with the greenbacks will probably have to pack it in if they can't get the convention endorsement.

Remember, this is just an opinion. If you have comments, please make them. If you want to pass along information that is pertinent to your particular candidate, my e-mail address is at the top. So, without furthur ado, the August rankings:

11. Tom Rukavina (formerly #10): Still finding his place in a crowded field. Guess we are all waiting for the patented Rukavinia sound bites to rise to the occasion and get him some press. They will come, I'm sure. Meanwhile he has to work his way up the ladder.

10. Susan Gaertner (formerly #7): Gaertner's message is fine and her stance on the issues have a broad DFL appeal, but she continues to be dogged by the RNC situation. Persistent protesters are following her everywhere -- even to Chicago. Fair or unfair, it is a distraction she doesn't need for a gubernatorial campaign.

9. Steve Kelley (formerly #11): Kelley moves up a couple of places. He has been working hard on grass roots development and also in alternative media. Still a ways to go, but his previous support from 2006 is still relevant. Money is a real key for him.

8. Tom Bakk (formerly #8): Bakk has been writing some good op-ed pieces and his focus on jobs is the right one, but as chair of the Senate Tax Committee, he is also going to have to have a good answer for increasing taxes. His committee proposed a bill that did just that and he will need to defend that as well as emphasize jobs. His message needs tweaking if it is to withstand election scrutiny. Treading water so far.

7. John Marty (formerly #9): Marty moves up a couple of places because he will attract a significant number of delegates with his strong single payer stand. He does not shy away from it and boldly defends it. Maybe that is a hard position to make for a general election, but it makes him a player for the convention. You have to admire his stance on principle...but is that going to win in November? -- its up to Marty to make that case.

6. Paul Thissen (formerly #6): Thissen is still doing the hard work that can give him an edge for the convention. He is making the appearances and doing the house parties. His strategy will probably have to concentrate on an endorsement. He doesn't yet have the name recognition to compete in a statewide primary without it.

5. Chris Coleman (formerly #5): Can't decide if Coleman is moving down or up -- so I'll keep him at #5. He's obviously interested in a governor run -- his beefed up staffing isn't needed for a mayoral re-election. But how he transitions from his current election to the next is tricky. Rybak is a little more open about it and he has the Draft RT group working outside his campaign. We'll know more soon.

4. Margaret Anderson Kelliher (formerly #4): She gets a little help from the GOP in her quest. They attack her with a billboard at the State Fair....nothing says fundraising, like a billboard slam. She still has some work to do and the 2010 session will make or break her candidacy. She will be the symbolic face of how the legislature fares in the mind of the public -- good or bad.

Still looking at the primary triumvarate.....

3. R.T. Rybak (formerly #3): The DraftRT group has a booth at the fair and are signing people up....that sure can't hurt a potential candidate for governor. The mayor has to continue to engage Pawlenty on issues at every opportunity and make some progress outstate. Its a challenge for a large city mayor, but Rybak seems to be working on it. He has to have a big showing at the straw poll on the 15th.

2. Mark Dayton (formerly #1): Dayton is still doing all the right things....making lots of grass roots connections and calling in markers from many years with the party. Still you have the feeling that he needs something else...that something is missing. He has been showing some more passion in his speeches and his issues are sharpening. He has made some bold pronouncements on raising taxes on the wealthy and regarding single payer health care. I would hope that he would also be ready to make those arguments in a general election as well.

1. Matt Entenza (formerly #2): I flipped Mark and Matt because of the Entenza additon of Dana Houle to his staff....and the excellent press he received during his southern Minnesota swing. Entenza's campaign staff is looking very strong and I would imagine his coffers are ready to do whatever is needed. Lois Quam has been more vocal of late on health care issues as well. Still there just seems to be that lack of passion in Matt -- almost robotic. A true policy wonk, he needs to get beyond that and speak to the heart of the average voter.

Most of this is, of course, a lot of speculation. The more telling items to watch will be financial reports and the polls that will start to pop up during the winter months.

Still, I don't see this field getting reduced for some time and frankly, that is good for policy debate. Take part in it.
comments (6) permalink
09/06/09 16:41
Matt Entenza's lies will eventually catch up to him, both among DFL activists he's screwed and nonactivists who remember his sleazy actions in his aborted AG campaign and other unethical campaign behavior. And all of Entenza's wife's money won't do much to salve those wounds. Entenza would do well to remember the advice from an old Allan Toussaint song:

"The same people you misuse on your way up,
You might meet up on your way down"

 
09/02/09 12:04
Good comments...all of them. But here is my reasoning on Dayton. Regardless of what happens at the convention, Dayton will be going on to the primary and has the money to pursue it. Despite some of the legitimate questions that surround the way he left the Senate, Dayton, if memory serves me correctly, has never lost a statewide campaign. He has also garnered support among the peace activists. They caucus, they are delegates, and they work hard for candidates they support. I still believe Dayton deserves his slot.
 
B
09/02/09 11:48
I think your rankings are off. Got a lot of respect for your blog but if I were to rank them I would play this way:

1. Matt Entenza – Money wins in politics – at least that is what some people say. He just picked up a good campaign hire (although not from MN). He has good consultants. He, however, is a bit boring and will have a hard time getting energy flowing (as you noted). I mean, anyone who threatens candidates a year out with the $10 million number has a lot of cash to buy people – let’s see if Democrats chose to ignore the past because of how much lit he sends or ads he runs.

2. Margaret Anderson Kelliher – silly not to put her second. Everyone has here there, Republicans are attacking her like crazy and ME or MAK are the candidates to beat. She will tons of women money, lots of labor support and has Jaime Tincher – a true rockstar. Additionally, Matt and Margaret have been dominating state house races as the House leaders and I can only imagine they will have more local people endorsing them than other candidates. MAK is the reason why we have a majority, her campaign structure is the reason why we build the majority. Legislative session could have ended better but how? I would like to hear someone give a reasonable idea that would be productive and not counterproductive. Hold a bill back? We would still be in session and that would be bad for the DFL and our groups. Pawlenty doesn’t care about MN and has nothing to lose. Margaret held it all together.

3. John Marty – I think Senator Marty is a good guy. I think if he is our candidate we will lose. That being said democrats love single payer and if he can mobilize these people for the Caucuses expect him to come in towards the top and surprise some people.

4. RT Rybak – I think RT is a good guy. I think that if he is our candidate, and remains fairly liberal, we will lose. Lots of anti-Obama flowing and he is the face of Obama in Minnesota. If he gets Obama people to the Caucuses he will do great – otherwise he will flounder ala Wes Clark. He is coming in too late to get any endorsements for local elected officials and that will hurt his chances. My advice – wait for four years – you are strong and could kick some butt – its just not your time.

5. Mark Dayton – he only gets this spot because of name recognition and money. He had some fairly public gaffes as an United States Senator. It will be interesting to see what he does but you are totally wrong about grassroots support and energy – every single person I have talked too puts him towards the bottom of the heap.

6. Thissen – totally agree with your analysis. He is incredibly smart, good organization and has been gathering money. I wonder with Coleman and RT jump in if it could shore up some of his money. He could easily take John Marty’s place as Thissen is strong on health care and other issues and doesn’t have baggage of a large electoral defeat statewide. Again, it would be great if Paul waited. He is incredibly intelligent, hard-working and charismatic.

7. Tom Rukavina – this is the dark horse sleeper. The old guard democrats will respond well to Rukavina. If he gets a good staff, a good schedule and shows up to talk in a crowded field – he will stand out. If Obama’s people stay home – expect a Croatian Sensation Surprise.

8. Chris Coleman – I have been to St. Paul events where once he is done – his liberal constituents say how boring he was. He doesn’t have the energy needed to win. John Stiles is a good pick and he just built a new website and hired consultants – I think no one in St. Paul will be impressed that he is ditching them to run for Governor in an overly crowded field. He won’t bring many, if any, endorsements and will be way to far behind in the game. He doesn’t have the appeal that RT does so he cannot come climbing back up.

9. The rest. Sorry but Tom Bakk will bring a few labor people who will endorse him because they owe him and because he is a labor guy – having other labor people like Rukavina and strong labor candidates like Margaret and Mark make it hard though to rise above the fray. Bakk also designed the largest tax hike in Minnesota and I don’t think that even Democrats will be a huge fan – especially when they find out he forgot to vote for his bill or didn’t support his bill. Steve Kelley is a brilliant man and should stay at the Humphrey crafting young minds for years to come. He can’t win an election – his record is pretty solid on that. Susan who? Very nice person – incredibly kind and hard-working. Its too bad she is stepping down as Attorney and will likely be replaced by John Choi who is arrogant and aloof. All of her women money will be taken by Tarryl for Congress and Margaret for Governor. Too many lawyers to take that cash.
 
Steve @ www.MNDem.com
09/01/09 11:16
Thanks again Dave. I love this stuff. I would move Matt down. You said he is "almost robotic." From people I have been talking to, they feel he isn't really connecting. And I agree with Dyna, move MAK up. She is getting a lot of attention. I think it is already turning into a race between the top four you have listed. And a couple of people I like a lot further down your list are probably going to be get nudged out. Great job.
 
09/01/09 10:06
john marty all the way!
 
08/31/09 19:14
Excellent analysis! I'd rate Tom Rukavina a little higher though- he's taken up organic gardening and is even tweeting, which will blow his whole image as an old skool populist firebrand. I'd put MAK slightly ahead of RT- I was out in western Minnesota last weekend and the DFLers there seemed to prefer Margaret and Matt Entenza.
 
« First « Previous

Calendar

« July 2010 »
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31


Archive


Categories



Comments


Links


RSS Feeds

RSS 0.91
RSS 2.0

 
 
 
Powered by
Powered by SBlog
 
Copyright © Minnesota Network for Progressive Action. All rights reserved. Legal. Privacy Policy. Sitemap.